Keurig Supreme vs Supreme Plus
Keurig is arguably the most well-known brand of coffee makers in America and its popularity even extends to a global scale. Among their most high-performing machines is the Keurig Supreme, which sports a compact design and superior extraction methods to deliver quality coffee at the push of a button.
A notch above this machine in terms of additional perks is the Keurig K Supreme Plus, which takes the foundation laid by the Keurig K Supreme and amps things up for better or worse. In this Keurig Supreme vs Supreme Plus review, all the information about these two similar yet different products will be detailed in a way that can help customers make the purchase that is best for them.
What is Keurig Supreme?
The Keurig K Supreme is a compact coffee maker that utilizes multistream brewing technology to extract coffee from a K-Cup and dispense it into a mug at a variety of cup sizes.
The machine is made of a plastic material and features a transparent water reservoir capacity of 66 ounces. This means it can brew up to 8 cups of coffee before a refill of water is required.
The Keurig K Supreme comes with multiple options for brew sizes including 6, 8, 10, or 12 oz cups. It also comes with a strong brew option and an over-ice option for iced coffee brewing, making it a versatile coffee machine that caters to a variety of users.
You can read all the details in our Keurig Supreme Review.
What is Supreme Plus?
The Keurig K Supreme Plus is a compact single-serve coffee maker made of stainless steel materials for more durable construction. It also uses multistream technology to extract the optimal flavor and aroma from the user’s K-Cup pod for a more enriching drinking experience.
The Keurig K Supreme Plus provides a programmable favorites feature that enables users to save their individual brewing preferences for up to three people. Furthermore, this coffee maker comes with strength control, temperature control, and a digital display screen.
The Supreme Plus aims to outdo the Keurig Supreme by offering a larger water tank of 78 oz as well as an additional brew size to also include 4 oz cups.
You can read all the details in our Keurig K Supreme Plus Review.
How are they different?
The most striking difference when it comes to the K Supreme Plus vs the Keurig Supreme is the material used in their respective constructions which give each one a slightly different appearance. The K Supreme Plus comes with a more durable stainless steel design while the Keurig Supreme uses a simple plastic construction.
Other differences include the water reservoir sizes, cup sizes, control panel, and strength and temperature control functions. More often than not, the K Supreme offers more in each of these areas, but there are still critical reasons to consider the Keurig Supreme as well.
More notably still, the K Supreme Plus comes with a programmable favorites option that saves the user’s own individual brewing preferences for up to three people for a more customized, tailored coffee-drinking experience.
How are they similar?
Despite the differences in their construction, the Keurig Supreme and K Supreme Plus still have a very similar overall look in terms of product dimensions, size, and weight. Most of the machines’ functionalities also remain fairly similar, particularly with the use of multi-stream technology for optimal K-Cup coffee extraction.
Both machines come with a transparent water tank, removable drip tray, and pour-over ice button. In addition, both the Keurig K Supreme and Supreme Plus use a control panel with dedicated buttons for a strong brew and multiple cup size selections, most of which are the same (6, 8, 10, 12 oz).
What’s better about Keurig Supreme?
There are some features of the Keurig Supreme that make it a better choice than the Supreme Plus for the right customer. One such example is the water reservoir which may be smaller but comes with dual-position capabilities. This means you can readjust the reservoir in multiple different positions to best fit your kitchen counter space.
The Keurig Supreme is also slightly more compact with product dimensions of 14.84 x 10.12 x 14.41 inches compared to the Supreme Plus 16.02 x 10.63 x 14.33 inches. This difference is likely due to the smaller 66 oz water reservoir and more simplified control panel which enables more overall space due to a minimalist design.
Lastly, the Keurig Supreme is available at a lower price point than the K Supreme Plus due to its simpler design and smaller size.
What’s better about Supreme Plus?
The Supreme Plus excels when it comes to programmable features that enable more personalized coffee brewing compared to the Keurig Supreme. This Keurig machine provides options for brewing preferences that allow you to adjust the brew strength and temperature settings for a great-tasting cup of tailored coffee.
In addition, the larger water tank size of 78 ounces means you can brew at least 9 cups of coffee before a refill is required, resulting in less maintenance and an overall better experience. Another benefit of the Supreme Plus is the additional brewing options which include a 4-ounce size as well, catering to those who prefer a smaller coffee fix.
Finally, the Supreme Plus features a digital display screen that makes it easier to adjust your coffee preferences and navigate the brewer.
Who should get Keurig Supreme?
The Keurig Supreme is a great choice for coffee lovers that like to keep things simple. Most coffee drinkers would be more than satisfied with the available brewing options of the Keurig K Supreme.
With a smaller water reservoir and more compact product dimensions, it would be easier to fit the Keurig Supreme on your kitchen counter space no matter how tight the area is. To further accommodate its space-saving benefits, the water tank features a dual-position function that allows you to twist and turn it on the spot like a game of Tetris, ultimately providing even more flexibility when it comes to storage space.
Who should get Supreme Plus?
The K Supreme Plus is designed for those who seek something a little bigger and a little sturdier and are willing to pay the extra cost. A larger water tank and stainless steel construction are just some of the added benefits of this machine that you simply won’t get with the standard Keurig Supreme.
Of course, I would also recommend the Supreme Plus to those with a little extra kitchen counter space, particularly when you consider its slightly bulkier design and lack of a dual-position water reservoir.
Most importantly, however, the Supreme Plus is best for those seeking a personalized coffee-drinking experience, as its features for programmability and favorites options are perfect for the everyday coffee connoisseur.
Feature Comparison of Supreme vs Supreme Plus
Water Reservoir
Determining whether the Keurig Supreme or K Supreme Plus has the better water reservoir is largely a subjective matter, and it is difficult to choose an outright winner based on pure data, as it largely comes down to personal taste, needs, and individual circumstances.
With the Keurig Supreme, you get the pleasure of a dual-position 66 oz reservoir that makes it easier to position in tight spots of your kitchen benchtop. On the other hand, the K Supreme Plus offers a larger reservoir at 78 oz but without the benefit of dual-position capabilities.
However, despite a 12 oz difference between these two reservoirs, it really comes down to a difference of just one extra cup for the K Supreme Plus. As such, it is a small sacrifice and a worthwhile trade-off to go for the 66 adjustable water tank should it suit your preference.
Winner: Keurig Supreme
Material
As discussed earlier, the K Supreme Plus is significantly more durable in terms of materials and construction due to the use of stainless steel in its design. Contrastingly, the Keurig Supreme simply uses a plastic construction which, while making the coffee machine more lightweight, it also makes it far more susceptible to scratches and, in the worst case, fatal damage.
The benefits of a lightweight design due to plastic simply cannot contend with the short-to-long term benefits of durable stainless steel construction, so the K Supreme Plus has the edge in this regard.
Winner: K Supreme Plus
Brew Sizes
As far as brew sizes go, both the K Supreme Plus and the Keurig Supreme can brew cup sizes of 6, 8, 10, and 12 ounces at the push of a button. The K Supreme Plus, however, goes an extra step and includes a 4 oz size for those seeking a smaller cup of coffee.
Of course, some may prefer not to have this option simply because it creates a more simplified control panel (more on that later), however, there is always a benefit to having more options, and the vast majority would certainly prefer the added brew size as a convenient feature. Thus, the K Supreme Plus once again takes the cake on this one.
Winner: K Supreme Plus
Programmable Features
Looking deeper into the unique features of the Keurig K Supreme vs the K Supreme Plus, we can see that only the latter offers programmable features for tailor-made cups of coffee. This function lets up to three users control the brew temperature and strength for a hot cup or stronger cup of coffee as preferred.
With a digital display screen included, it’s easy to customize your coffee with the K Supreme Plus and choose between 3 strength levels and 3 temperature settings to brew your K Cup coffee pod the way you like it.
Unfortunately, the Keurig K Supreme model does not offer such a feature, meaning it simply cannot compete with the Supreme Plus on this one. Hence, the K Supreme Plus gets yet another win over its processor model on this occasion.
Winner: K Supreme Plus
Control Panel
That brings us to the final feature which is the control panel setup. While the Keurig K Supreme Plus comes with more functions such as programmable brewing, an extra brew size button, and a digital display window, this actually creates a shortcoming with the control panel. In retrospect, you can see that the K Supreme Plus is covered with an almost overwhelming amount of buttons and functions on its very small and compact button-control area.
In contrast, the humble Keurig Supreme simple has its cup size buttons and the default “strong brew” and “over ice” options. Moreover, as a result of the extra space on the Keurig Supreme, it’s able to include important features like “descale” and “add water” lights which help immensely in the cleaning and maintenance process.
Thus, despite the extra features and buttons on the Supreme Plus, the winner here will have to go to the Keurig Supreme for its simplified control panel that shines where it matters most.
Winner: Keurig Supreme
Final Thoughts
On a final note, we can see the contest between these two coffee makers is fierce, and while their differences are what make each one unique, it’s important to also remember their similarities too. For instance, both coffee makers can accept a reusable K-Cup and both can produce a chilled cup of coffee using the pre-ground coffee beans found in K-Cups. Furthermore, both machines come with a removable water tank and drip tray that can also accommodate for a taller travel mug.
The key differences lie in their respective exclusive features, with the K Supreme Plus offering the ability to brew multiple sizes including 4 ounces, while the Keurig Supreme features maintenance alert lights and a simpler design.
Regardless, the brewing process for both these machines use multiple streams of water contact with the coffee grounds that allows the coffee maker to brew directly for a more concentrated cup of coffee. This means that both the K Supreme Plus and the Keurig Supreme can brew strong cups of coffee or even go into over-ice mode to brew over ice cubes for a delicious iced coffee option too.
No matter which model you choose, you are guaranteed to have more control over the brewing process than other coffee makers on the market, so just make sure you know the key difference between each machine in terms of their unique features and you should have no issues making the best decision for your Keurig coffee maker purchase.
Our co-founder went with the Supreme and absolutely loves it. Check it out here.
Keurig Supreme vs Supreme Plus FAQ
What is the difference between Keurig Supreme and K-Supreme Plus?
The main difference between the Keurig Supreme vs K Supreme Plus is quite subtle in some features and rather extraordinary in others. In a nutshell, the Supreme Plus offers more functionality such as programmable brewing, more brew sizes, and coffee customization, while the Keurig Supreme offers a dual-position water reservoir and maintenance alert lights for added convenience.
Is Keurig K Supreme worth it?
The Keurig K Supreme is well-worth the investment despite its shortcomings, as it still boasts a range of features that even the more advanced Supreme Plus cannot contend with. These features include an adjustable water reservoir, a descale light and add water light, and a more simplified and lightweight design at a lower price point than the K Supreme Plus machine.
What does the Keurig Supreme Plus do?
Like many of the best Keurig machines, the Keurig K Supreme Plus utilizes multi-stream technology to extract all the coffee flavors from K-Cups in order to get the maximum richness and aroma out of the enclosed ground coffee. This Keurig coffee maker is built to produce freshly brewed coffee at the push of a button, turning your favorite coffee grounds into a delicious cup of full flavor coffee.
When did the Keurig Supreme Plus come out?
The Keurig Supreme Plus was released and first made available on the 23rd of August 2020 and has become a top-selling product by Keurig for the last few years since its release.
With sophisticated technology that more effectively extracts coffee from K-Cup pods, people are loving this machine which has received a 4.4-star rating on Amazon reviews by over 4,500 global customers and real users of this product.
Click here to buy the Supreme Plus
Related:
Keurig Slim vs Mini: Which is the right one?
Keurig Mini vs Mini Plus: Which is best?
