Are you someone who seeks moderation in life? Do you prefer a solid middle-ground to keep things well-balanced, stable, flexible, and versatile? When it comes to coffee makers, sometimes it’s best to have a not too fancy machine but not too basic either.
I’m talking about 5 cup coffee makers, that is, coffee makers built specifically to brew 5 cup carafes for the perfect middle-ground pot size. The Best 5 Cup Coffee Maker for you can be found in this article as we dive into the features, pros, and cons of some of the highest-rated 5 cup coffee makers on offer today!
Best 5 Cup Coffee Maker
Elite Gourmet Automatic Brew & Drip Coffee Maker
- Elite Gourmet Automatic Brew & Drip Coffee Maker
- Semi-transparent Water Reservoir
- 5 Cup Glass Carafe
- Reusable Coffee Filter
- Easy-View Water Window
- Easy-Clean Warming Plate
The Elite Gourmet Automatic Bew & Drip coffee maker comes with a 5-cup glass carafe that is transparent and includes measuring labels per cup. Also included is an easy-view window to monitor the reservoir’s water levels and a warming plate to keep your cups of coffee warm. Finally, this set comes with a reusable filter for your coffee grounds and a semi-transparent water tank.
- The glass carafe comes with measurement markings, a spill-proof spout, and a large ergonomic handle.
- The filter basket is removable, reusable, environmentally friendly, and dishwasher safe.
- The transparent water tank lets you monitor levels easier and refill when necessary.
- The warming plate is great for keeping coffee warm after the brewing process is complete.
- Quick and easy to use with a simple on/off light indicator switch.
- No programmable settings for brewing.
- No grinder or milk frother included.
Overall Elite Gourmet Automatic Brew & Drip Coffee Maker Review
The Elite Gourmet Coffee Maker comes with a pause brew feature that lets you pour yourself a cup while the machine works on filling up its carafe. Speaking of which, the carafe lid comes with a spill-proof spout, measurement labels, and an ergonomic handle.
While it lacks the programmable functions of other coffee makers, the simplicity of this machine is also part of its charm, making it the preferred 5-cup coffee maker for many people. Hence, it’s not surprising that almost 2,000 global users on Amazon rate this product an average of 4.4-stars because it certainly has the quality to back it up.
Bonavita 5 Cup Coffee Maker with Thermal Carafe
- Bonavita 5 Cup Coffee Maker with Thermal Carafe
- 5-Cup Thermal Carafe
- Pre-Infusion Mode and Showerhead Saturation
- Filter Basket
- Auto Shut-Off Feature
The Bonavita coffee maker features a thermal carafe that keeps coffee hot for longer. It also comes with an auto-shutoff function that automatically powers down the machine after a period of inactivity.
However, the stand-out feature lies in the pre-infusion mode and showerhead combination, which provides saturation of the ground coffee before extraction takes place for an evenly balanced flavor.
- The auto-off function allows you to save on energy and not worry about turning off your machine.
- The carafe is made of thermal material to prolong the temperature of your coffee.
- Enables pre-infusion with a showerhead that evenly saturates the coffee grounds before brewing to lock in the flavors.
- The enhanced heater quickly reaches and maintains the perfect brewing temperature.
- Gold-standard coffee approved by Coffee Enterprises for quality.
- The carafe is not see-through.
- Not compatible with coffee pods or capsules.
Overall Bonavita 5 Cup Coffee Maker with Thermal Carafe Review
The Bonavita 5 Cup coffee maker is a gold-standard brewer that delivers exceptional coffee using pre-infusion mode, which essentially works so that the brewing process pauses to allow the grounds to bloom and enable optimal coffee flavor extraction.
This works even better with the showerhead, which sprays the grounds to saturate evenly and create a more consistent flavor and richness from the first sip to the last drop of coffee. This SCA-approved coffee maker is rated 4.2-stars on Amazon reviews by over 2,200 global customers, regarded highly for its flavor, ease of use, and durability in material and craftsmanship.
Mr. Coffee 2129512, 5-Cup Mini Brew Switch Coffee Maker
- Mr. Coffee 2129512, 5-Cup Mini Brew Switch Coffee Maker
- Lift & Clean Filter Basket
- Grab-A-Cup Auto Pause
- 5-Cup Glass Carafe
- Easy-View Window
The Mr. Coffee 5-cup coffee maker comes with a glass coffee pot with measuring labels and a removable filter basket that is compatible with paper filters and reusable filters as preferred. It also comes with an auto-pause feature to pour yourself a cup mid-brew and an easy on/off switch.
- Easy to use with a single on/off switch accompanied by a light indicator.
- The carafe is transparent and has measuring markings to see how much coffee is left.
- The pause feature lets you pour yourself a cup mid-brew for extra convenience.
- The easy-view window lets you check the water levels to keep track and refill when low easily.
- Compact design with sleek black look is aesthetic and fits nicely in any kitchen counter space.
- Coffee filters are sold separately.
- No milk frother or grinder included.
Overall Mr. Coffee 2129512, 5-Cup Mini Brew Switch Coffee Maker Review
The Mr. Coffee 5-Cup Mini Brew is built to be as compact as they come. It sports a sleek black design that looks as good as it fits and can brew a 5-cup carafe at the push of a button. It includes a carafe that fits perfectly under the brewer, this machine is quite convenient.
Additionally, a 2-hour auto shut-off feature helps you save on energy and costs by turning off the power after 2 hours of inactivity. That way, you don’t have to worry if you head off to work and remember that you left it on! Rated a huge 4.4-stars by almost 10,000 global reviews, this product is regarded well for its flavor, ease of use, and ease of cleaning.
Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker
- Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker
- Hot Plate
- Drip Stop
- Gold-Tone Filter
- 5 Cup Glass Carafe
- Programmable Timer
The Capresso 5 Cup coffee maker uses a gold-tone filter to produce SCA-approved third-wave specialty coffee that is more flavorful and aromatic than regular coffee. It also comes with a warming plate to maintain temperature for hot coffee and a programmable timer and drip-stop function.
- A programmable coffee maker allows you to brew at a predetermined time.
- The drip stop feature prevents messes by sealing the spout and blocking the machine from further dripping after brewing.
- The gold-tone permanent filter allows you to enjoy the taste of SCA-approved coffee.
- Includes a carafe that is see-through and comes with measurement labels.
- Compact stainless steel design is great for storing in tight spots and offers lasting durability.
- No burr grinder or frother included.
- No customizable coffee options.
Overall Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker Review
For a delicious coffee that tastes great with no dramas, Capresso offers an easy-to-use solution that not only brews to an SCA-approved standard but also puts you in control with programmable options. This means you can set the machine to brew coffee at the precise time of your choosing (I’d recommend the morning!), so you get to cut out one extra step in your routine ahead of time.
Other than that, it’s a relatively simple machine with an excellent compact design made in a sleek black color and durable stainless steel material. Loved by customers everywhere, this machine is rated 4.5-stars by over 3,300 global reviews on Amazon. Check out the link below for a closer look at what people are saying about the Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip coffee maker now!
Kendal Glass Tabletop Siphon (Syphon) Coffee Maker
- Kendal Glass Tabletop Siphon (Syphon) Coffee Maker
- Heat Resistant Borosilicate Glass
- Alcohol Burner and Reusable Cloth Filter
- Coffee Powder Plastic Spoon and Bamboo Stirrer
This coffee maker is a siphon brewer that uses heat-resistant borosilicate glass, an alcohol burner, and a reusable cloth filter. Also featured are a coffee powder plastic spoon and bamboo stirrer that helps you measure the perfect amount of coffee and stir to perfection.
- Brews unique mellow coffee the traditional way.
- No need for bulky machinery and complex control panels.
- Brews smoother and cleaner coffee by maximizing the essential oils.
- Heat-resistant glass can withstand up to 300 degrees F.
- Extra accessories such as coffee spoon and stirrer for added convenience.
- No programmable features.
- No frother or burr grinder included.
Overall Kendal Glass Tabletop Siphon (Syphon) Coffee Maker Review
The Kendal Glass Tabletop Siphon coffee maker is significantly different from the usual coffee machines on this list. It needs an acquired taste to appreciate it fully. While it produces a taste just as good as most coffee makers, it’s the brewing process itself that is a lot more hands-on, so don’t expect to have delicious coffee at the push of a button with this one.
On the other hand, it’s easier and more intimate to control the Kendal Siphon’s temperature, ratios, extraction pressure, and brew strength. If that appeals to you, then know that this is one of the best in the business for siphon coffee making. In fact, it’s good enough to receive a 4.5-stars on Amazon reviews by almost 200 customers. Use the link below to see what people are saying about Kendal now!
KRUPS Simply Brew Compact Filter Drip Coffee Maker
- KRUPS Simply Brew Compact Filter Drip Coffee Maker
- Removable Cone Filter
- Premium Black Stainless Steel Finish
- Dishwasher Safe Glass Coffee Pot
- Measuring Spoon
This 5 cup coffee maker by KRUPS features a stainless steel compact design and a carafe with drip-free pouring made of sturdy glass. It comes with a one-touch operation for simple brewing and a pause-and-serve feature to pour yourself a cup of coffee mid-brew.
- Compact design made of durable stainless steel and beautiful sleek black colors.
- Keeping warm function means you can enjoy hot coffee long after the brewing cycle is over.
- The coffee maker’s carafe is drip-free and includes measuring labels.
- A permanent filter means no messy paper filters are needed.
- Large door opening for easy water reservoir refilling.
- The filter is not gold-tone SCA standard.
- No programmable timer.
Overall KRUPS Simply Brew Compact Filter Drip Coffee Maker Review
The KRUPS 5 cup coffee maker is a compact drip coffee maker that brews fresh coffee at the push of a button. In addition, it comes with various extra coffee equipment such as a reusable permanent coffee filter, carafe, and coffee spoon.
A small coffee maker that is easy to use, the KRUPS machine enables a hot cup of coffee well after you’ve finished brewing, thanks to the hot plate that keeps temperatures high. Loved by thousands of people worldwide, this 5 cup coffee maker is rated 4.4-stars by over 8,700 global users. Check out what people are saying about it using the link to Amazon reviews below:
BLACK+DECKER 5-Cup Coffeemaker, Black
- BLACK+DECKER 5-Cup Coffeemaker, Black
- Duralife Glass Carafe
- Nonstick Carafe Plate
- Removable Basket Filter
The Black and Decker 5 cup coffee maker comes with a durable glass carafe and a removable filter basket. Also included are convenient cord storage, a water window viewer, and a light on/off switch, as well as a 2-year warranty.
- The durable glass carafe is stronger and sturdier than most glass carafes.
- The removable brew basket is compatible with basket-style paper filters.
- Convenient cord storage keeps your countertop nice and tidy.
- The water window makes it easy to keep track of reservoir levels.
- The 2-year warranty gives peace of mind with the purchase.
- No programmable brewing features.
- No reusable filter included.
Overall BLACK+DECKER 5-Cup Coffeemaker Review
The Black and Decker 5 cup coffee maker is a simple but effective machine with a dishwasher-safe filter basket and a durable glass carafe for easy pouring. It works with a simple on/off switch with no complex controls and works with all kinds of paper filters. It’s the perfect coffee maker for the home and the workplace, wherever your coffee-drinking haven may be.
Rated 4.4-stars from over 4,200 global customers, this product is regarded highly for its use in small spaces, ease of cleaning, and ease of use. Check out the customer feedback comments using the link to Amazon reviews here!
Holstein Housewares – 5-Cup Compact Coffee Maker
- Holstein Housewares – 5-Cup Compact Coffee Maker
- Measuring Spoon
- Removable Cone Filter
- 5 Cup Carafe
Holstein Housewares brings us this 5 cups compact machine that brews up to 5 cups of coffee per cycle with a removable filter and glass carafe that rests on a nonstick warming plate. It also comes with a pause feature for mid-brew pouring and a user-friendly one-touch operation.
- The beautiful aesthetic blue color brightens up the room.
- The auto-pause function lets you pour a cup mid-brew.
- A reusable filter eliminates the need for paper filters.
- Available in a variety of colors.
- 1-year limited warranty.
- No programmable timer included.
- No burr grinder or frother included.
Overall Holstein Housewares – 5-Cup Compact Coffee Maker Review
The Holstein Housewares 5-cup coffee maker is a compact machine that can appeal to any coffee lover with its fantastic range of bright color options and user-friendly one-touch operation. It also comes with a reusable filter, so you won’t need to bother changing out used paper filters all the time, and you can also pour yourself a cup mid-brew with the pause function!
Rated 4.3-stars by over 6,100 global users on Amazon reviews, I’d recommend this machine purely for its choices of color, which are hard to come by with all the coffee makers on the market. Check out what people are saying with the link below!
Gevi Coffee Maker, 5 Cups Small Programmable Coffee Machine with Reusable Filter
- Gevi Coffee Maker, 5 Cups Small Programmable Coffee Machine with Reusable Filter
- Programmable Features
- Keep Warm Function
- Reusable Filter
- 30s Auto Pause
This coffee maker makes brewing coffee simple with a one-touch brew button and auto-pause feature. It also can do more complex things like programmable brewing at a specified time for extra convenience up to 24 hours.
- Digital timer display allows you to program the timing of your brew.
- Auto-pause feature for mid-brew pouring.
- Drip-free function kicks in 30 seconds after brewing to avoid mess.
- A warming plate keeps coffee nice and hot for hours.
- Compact design provides space-saving advantages.
- Not compatible with coffee pods.
- The carafe is not thermal.
Overall Gevi Coffee Maker, 5 Cups Small Programmable Coffee Machine with Reusable Filter Review
The Gevi 5 cup coffee maker is programmable so that you can set the time of your brew to bring out that delicious coffee as soon as you wake up. Unlike most other five-cup coffee makers, this one features an LCD digital display for easy brew control.
Additionally, it is backed by overheating protection, a 2-hour auto-shutoff feature, and a 2-hour keep-warm function. A solid rating for a solid machine, the Gevi scores a 4.3-stars by over 1,700 global reviewers on Amazon. Check out what they are saying using the link below!
BOSCARE Coffee Maker with Reusable Filter
- BOSCARE Coffee Maker with Reusable Filter
- Hot Plate
The BOSCARE comes with fast brewing and a reusable filter to make coffee fast and convenient. It also comes with a unique nonstick warming plate to keep coffee hot for an hour.
- The warming plate is nonstick and keeps coffee hot for n hour.
- Reusable filter for easy maintenance.
- Fast brewing allows timely coffee for morning rushes.
- One-touch brewing is easy to use.
- Compact size fits anywhere in your kitchen.
- No milk frother.
- No programmable options.
Overall BOSCARE Coffee Maker with Reusable Filter Review
Another great 5 cup coffee maker is the BOSCARE which comes with a reusable filter that retains coffee oils for a richer flavor and a nonstick hot plate that keeps brewed coffee warm for an hour. With fast brewing via quick heat-up time and a one-touch operation, getting your hands on a quick cup first thing in the morning is easy.
This machine gets a 3.8-star rating on Amazon reviews by over 500 customers, making it a satisfactory machine that gets the job done. Check out the comments down below:
Amazon Basics 5-Cup (25 Oz) Coffeemaker with Glass Carafe
- Amazon Basics 5-Cup (25 Oz) Coffeemaker with Glass Carafe
- Removable Filter Basket
- 1-Year Warranty
Brought to you by Amazon themselves, this machine comes with a 25 oz glass carafe, removable filter basket, and a 1-year warranty for any factory defects. It also has an anti-drip function and an auto-shutoff function.
- A removable filter means no paper filters are needed.
- Durable glass carafe for easy pouring.
- The anti-drip function prevents messes.
- Auto-off function saves energy for your house.
- 1-year product warranty.
- No programmable brewing.
- The carafe is not dishwasher-friendly.
Overall Amazon Basics 5-Cup (25 Oz) Coffeemaker with Glass Carafe Review
This machine is a simple one-touch brewer specializing in producing delicious coffee taste at the push of a button. Unlike other drip coffee makers, Amazon offers a 1-year warranty for factory defects, making it one of the better coffee deals out there.
Coffee lovers everywhere like this machine, which received a 4.4-star rating from almost 12,000 happy Amazon customers. Check out what people are saying about the Amazon Basics coffee maker using the link below!
5 Cup Coffee Maker Buying Guide
If you’re someone who forgets to turn off your machine after use, definitely look for the auto-off feature for your next purchase. This can save you energy and is generally good for the environment, so you won’t need to stress about surprising electricity bills!
Compact design and size
As I’ve mentioned, 5 cup coffee makers are the middle-ground, so while they are generally considered small coffee makers, they are also large enough to fit a 5 cup carafe. Make sure you go for something that fits somewhere in your kitchen space (or wherever you brew), and you may want also to consider cord storage.
Brewing speed and temperature
Look out for machines with superior heating elements if you prefer speedy brews, as machines tend to differ in this aspect. Also, go for a pause-and-serve feature machine to get your hands on a cup faster for when you are in dire need of coffee.
Most 5 cup machines are easy to clean by default, but look for ones with dishwasher-safe components for even more convenience, especially if you advocate for dishwashers like myself! You may also want to consider a more straightforward descaling system for your machine, so read the product descriptions thoroughly.